A terrible Black Panther comic (and series overall)
Review for Black Panther: The Man Without Fear 515-A

Comic Book by Marvel, Apr 01 2011
     
 
  Details   Reviews   Stats    

Review By

     

SwiftMann
April 04, 2011

A terrible Black Panther comic (and series overall)

This series has been dreadful, boring crap.

Starting with the repetitive Simone Bianchi covers - two of the three have focal points on T'Challa's knee protector. I don't know why DC and Marvel have such a love for Bianchi, but I find his art terrible and his perspectives awkward.

The interior art by Francesco Francavilla, who does everything (pencils, inks & colors) is dull and muddy. I'm finding more and more when an artist does all the work, particularly the colors, the art fails to engage the reader. Here we get very boring layouts, very boring artwork and horrible coloring of mostly black, brown and yellow.

All that said about the visuals, the biggest offender here is David Liss and the overall story and specifically the dialogue. I've read most of the Black Panther comics from the last 15 years and while it doesn't make much sense for him to give up everything (and everyone, including his wife) to live a fake life and protect Hell's Kitchen, I'm willing to buy it as a premise. But, when you throw in horribly cliched Russian mobster named, ugh, Vlad the Impaler (with the stilted, broken English - a pet peeve of mine) and his inept sons and have half of each issue focusing on them, it's hardly a Black Panther comic at all. T'Challa's supporting cast of Moon Knight also-rans comes off as completely forced. Add to that the unbelievable characterization of T'Challa in his attempts to adjust to life in Hell's Kitchen (he shouldn't be inept at being and average Joe like Liss writes him), choppy, unnatural dialogue from every character (it's like some weird bastardization of Bendis-speak) and I find every aspect of Liss' work to be completely missing the point and/or painfully boring and cliched.

Part of the awkward dialogue (other than the cliched broken English) is that T'Challa and Vlad almost never use contractions. That's definitely creating some of the stilted dialogue issues. But the "crazy" plot turns of T'Challa and the wife and the son and the doctor are eyerolling inducing. And, sweet Yoda, the dialogue between the son and the doctor is almost worth retyping in full for it's cheesy glory, instead I'll just paraphrase the two pages - "We will go behind your father's back and steal his powers." "He's so stupid and trusting." "And not as handsome." "Let's not go there, doctor." "I hope your father won't be angry, he seems angry." "What he doesn't know won't hurt him.").

After reading this issue, I've stopped pre-ordering this title. Awful stuff.

Comments

Bristow1
Agreed, T'Challa would have zero problems adjusting. This guy just took on Doctor Doom and suddenly is having problems with a nobody?!?!
The_Valiant_One
Poop wrapped in sunshine? Still poop. ;) Good review.

My ComicCollectorLive
Not in Wishlist Wishlist
No
Not in a Current Order Ordered
No
Not in a Cart In Cart
No

On Sale Now

Sort
Cloud City Comics and Toys
CloudCityComics
Hero Mortal Villan
822 31 32
  • Satisfaction Rate: 96%
Under A Buck Books
ftmmusic
Hero Mortal Villan
756 6 3
  • Satisfaction Rate: 98%
Boyne City Comics
lewis1234
Hero Mortal Villan
91 0 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Read The Story (Play the Game) - Reserve with us for savings!
PTGRTS
Hero Mortal Villan
5778 17 3
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Pawl's Attic
pawlsattic2
Hero Mortal Villan
1043 6 2
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Timeboomerang
podolj
Hero Mortal Villan
173 0 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Swifty's Olde Tyme Comic Shoppe
SwiftMann
Hero Mortal Villan
218 0 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
B&D COMIC SHOP
BDCOMICS
Hero Mortal Villan
968 2 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
UNTAMED WORLDS- Subscribe with us and save!
untamedworlds
Hero Mortal Villan
417 1 1
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Multiverse Comic Books and More
HT
Hero Mortal Villan
96 2 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
ADC's Collection
DRUMCZAR
Hero Mortal Villan
773 1 1
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%