Log In Forums Help
Comic Collector Live
Home :: CCL Messageboard
Find Comics for Sale
Items For Sale
All Comics For Sale
New Releases
CGC Comics
Bundled Lots
Store Locator
Search Library
Search By Title
Publisher
Story Arc
Character
Credits
Release Date
Change Request Manager
News & Reviews
Reviews
News
Our Products and Services
Get the Software
Buying Comics And Stuff
Selling Your Comics
Opening A Store
Community
Forum
Store Locator
Member Locator
Welcome Guest Active Topics
CR Request Homage Covers Options
DivideAndConquer
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 1:42:25 PM

Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Super Seller

Joined: 5/7/2013
Posts: 493
Points: 1,522
Going through a recent stack of pickups I came across something that I don't know if it has ever been brought up.

The tag is labeled Homage Cover X-Men 136. Famous cover and it has been used as design by different artist. Hence the homage. The comic was release I. August 1980.

If you look at the cover for Super man's girlfriend 128 you will notice that the cover art is extremely simular. The depiction is the same. This comic has a publish date of December 1972.


http://www.comiccollectorlive.com/LiveData/Issue.aspx?id=5b263ec2-3dcc-4bd4-b804-87eaef8ec1f3

This is a full 8 years prior to the X MEN issue. The X men issue looks to be a copy of this very cover. Now I know that marvel and x men people will look at the the relevance of each issue and the x men issue being more of a "key issue", I am wondering what the rules are on Homages. Is it strictly off date or is it off of the keyness of the issue or popularity? I could land either way, but I have to side with date because I believe the concept of a cover should weigh more than the issues individual key.

Look forward to talking this one out.

Dylan

Free Media Mail Shipping @ $35

$0.35 AND $0.50 BARGAIN BIN

Customized International Shipping Options!

All comics 1.01 and up come Bagged and Boarded at no additional cost. All other comics are bagged at no additional cost!

Like us on Facebook!
Facebook

Follow us on Twitter for Hot Invest Comics News and Promotion Sales!
Twitter

www.dandccomics.com
COMING SOON!!!
chiller67
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 2:05:37 PM

Rank: Herald of Galactus
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/1/2007
Posts: 2,198
Points: 33,210
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
These covers are all loosely based on Michaelangelo's "Pieta" sculpture which depicts a dead Christ being held in the arms of his mother, Mary.
I'm sure that predates them by a few hundred years lol.
They go all the way back to the 50's as far as I'm aware. I can't find the specific "first" time it was used in comics - an old sci-fi/monster comic IIRC.
In my opinion, for what it's worth, "Pieta" cover would be the most appropriate name for them.

Here's an article I managed to find with a quick google search

http://comiccoverage.typepad.com/comic_coverage/2007/04/comic_book_cove.html
jbeeman85
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 2:09:53 PM

Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Subscriber

Joined: 7/11/2011
Posts: 460
Points: 1,474
Location: Nashville, TN
It seems to be that X-Men is paying homage to the Superman cover. It is incredibly similar and the Superman cover came out about 8 years earlier. But I see as I was typing this someone added a link to "Pieta" covers so I will side with chiller and say that they are all paying homage to that sculpture.
DivideAndConquer
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 2:11:54 PM

Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Super Seller

Joined: 5/7/2013
Posts: 493
Points: 1,522
What was that.... MIND BLOWN... I can't believe I didn't make the correlation. You would think the minor in History I have would have helped make the correlation. Awesome info.

Free Media Mail Shipping @ $35

$0.35 AND $0.50 BARGAIN BIN

Customized International Shipping Options!

All comics 1.01 and up come Bagged and Boarded at no additional cost. All other comics are bagged at no additional cost!

Like us on Facebook!
Facebook

Follow us on Twitter for Hot Invest Comics News and Promotion Sales!
Twitter

www.dandccomics.com
COMING SOON!!!
icarus201
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 4:28:00 PM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CR-Policies, Member, Moderator, Movies Host, Subscriber, UK Host

Joined: 8/17/2007
Posts: 42,771
Points: 524,688
Location: United Kingdom
I think a new tag for "Pieta" homage should be made for all those covers pre-dating X-Men #136 and Crisis #7.


Marvel Universe® ~ No-one Ever Really Dies.

Make sure that you read and understand the forum rules here
outcast
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 9:52:35 PM
Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Newsstand Edition Host

Joined: 7/28/2012
Posts: 424
Points: 1,858
Not to forget Conan the Barbarian 100 (July 1979).

DivideAndConquer
Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2014 10:53:47 PM

Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Super Seller

Joined: 5/7/2013
Posts: 493
Points: 1,522
icarus201 wrote:
I think a new tag for "Pieta" homage should be made for all those covers pre-dating X-Men #136 and Crisis #7.

How many votes need to happen for this to be "changed"?

Free Media Mail Shipping @ $35

$0.35 AND $0.50 BARGAIN BIN

Customized International Shipping Options!

All comics 1.01 and up come Bagged and Boarded at no additional cost. All other comics are bagged at no additional cost!

Like us on Facebook!
Facebook

Follow us on Twitter for Hot Invest Comics News and Promotion Sales!
Twitter

www.dandccomics.com
COMING SOON!!!
icarus201
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 7:06:52 AM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CR-Policies, Member, Moderator, Movies Host, Subscriber, UK Host

Joined: 8/17/2007
Posts: 42,771
Points: 524,688
Location: United Kingdom
DivideAndConquer wrote:
icarus201 wrote:
I think a new tag for "Pieta" homage should be made for all those covers pre-dating X-Men #136 and Crisis #7.

How many votes need to happen for this to be "changed"?

I've submitted the request;
http://www.comiccollectorlive.com/Change/ListItem_Edit.aspx?id=569c572f-fdb0-4c36-bd21-e44ead5cf6a1&class=4


Marvel Universe® ~ No-one Ever Really Dies.

Make sure that you read and understand the forum rules here
DivideAndConquer
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 7:13:09 AM

Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Super Seller

Joined: 5/7/2013
Posts: 493
Points: 1,522
Awesome. I have made my vote. Thanks everyone for some super information!!

Free Media Mail Shipping @ $35

$0.35 AND $0.50 BARGAIN BIN

Customized International Shipping Options!

All comics 1.01 and up come Bagged and Boarded at no additional cost. All other comics are bagged at no additional cost!

Like us on Facebook!
Facebook

Follow us on Twitter for Hot Invest Comics News and Promotion Sales!
Twitter

www.dandccomics.com
COMING SOON!!!
outcast
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 6:06:32 PM
Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Newsstand Edition Host

Joined: 7/28/2012
Posts: 424
Points: 1,858
Eddy Current 6 (Feb. 1988) comes as close to the actual Pieta as any comic I can think of, right down to the nun's left hand.

icarus201
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 6:15:22 PM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CR-Policies, Member, Moderator, Movies Host, Subscriber, UK Host

Joined: 8/17/2007
Posts: 42,771
Points: 524,688
Location: United Kingdom
outcast wrote:
Eddy Current 6 (Feb. 1988) comes as close to the actual Pieta as any comic I can think of, right down to the nun's left hand.


You've never seen this?




Marvel Universe® ~ No-one Ever Really Dies.

Make sure that you read and understand the forum rules here
Thundercron
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 6:55:26 PM

Rank: Herald of Galactus
Groups: Member, Super Seller

Shop at My Store

Joined: 9/14/2008
Posts: 2,466
Points: 31,853
Location: Vancouver, Washington
outcast wrote:
Not to forget Conan the Barbarian 100 (July 1979).



I don't know....so every time a character is holding a dead loved one in their arms like that, it's a homage to Pieta? Isn't it possible that some of these covers are just dudes holding dead bodies?

Here's one from the cover gallery above:



I just don't see it. He's holding Tarianna because she dies, and he spends several pages of the book talking to her while she's in The Thing's arms. I really don't think the cover artist thought, "Hey, I really liked that Pieta sculpture. I think I'll pay tribute to it on the cover."

My point is--all these should not be Pieta homage covers.
outcast
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 9:27:43 PM
Rank: Large Noggin
Groups: Member, Newsstand Edition Host

Joined: 7/28/2012
Posts: 424
Points: 1,858
@ Thundercron:

Good point. My citation of the Conan cover may have been a step too far.

If Pieta tags were limited to deliberate, specific homages to the Michelangelo statue (Eddy Current, Death of Captain Marvel, and perhaps others not yet identified), I wouldn't complain.
padreglcc
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 10:06:09 PM

Rank: Celestial
Groups: Approver, CR-Guidelines, CR-Management, DC Host, Forum Admin, Member, Moderator, New Releases Host, Reviews Host, Subscriber

Joined: 5/6/2007
Posts: 4,266
Points: 475,808
Location: Bangor, Michigan
outcast wrote:
@ Thundercron:

Good point. My citation of the Conan cover may have been a step too far.

If Pieta tags were limited to deliberate, specific homages to the Michelangelo statue (Eddy Current, Death of Captain Marvel, and perhaps others not yet identified), I wouldn't complain.


Harbinger (1992) #14 and Captain Atom (1998) #8 are other good examples of direct homages to the Pieta.





In general though, I think many covers, while perhaps paying respect the Pieta, aren't really homages of that cover. They're homages of either X-Men #136 or (as suggested earlier in the thread) of Lois Lane #128. I think that the X-Men book got the tag simply since it was a better known book. The tag should really either be changed to the Lois Lane book or at the very least shared between them. That's not to say that I'm against a Pieta tag, but just think it should be used pretty selectively.

“One of the most sincere forms of respect is actually listening to what another has to say.” ~ Bryant H. McGill

Please make sure you read and understand the Forum Rules here.
SwiftMann
Posted: Friday, March 07, 2014 10:38:48 PM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CCL Feature Crew, CR-Guidelines, Member, Super Seller

Shop at My Store

Joined: 4/19/2007
Posts: 11,327
Points: 1,928,598
Location: PA
I've seen the argument for a lot of "someone holding a dead body" covers to be homages to either the pieta or Uncanny.

I don't agree.

{I hate that these aren't showing side-by-side. Stupid forum dimensions.)



These two are almost identical images. From Superman's copied grimace to the direction of the head-cock to which leg is higher on the dead's body to the to the flatness of the feet. When you put these in separate tabs of a browser and flip back and forth, it's nearly identical.




As for these two, while similar they aren't the same. Inspired? Perhaps, but not a direct homage.

There's no question Crisis came from X-Men. And unless there's something somewhere stating that X-Men is from Lois Lane, I don't believe it's an assumption we make as there's only so many ways to draw "holding a dead body."

Has DC Done Something Stupid Today?

"The return of beards and 90's fashion makes hipsters and homeless people impossible to tell apart." - Woody, Quantum & Woody #5
icarus201
Posted: Saturday, March 08, 2014 6:21:31 AM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CR-Policies, Member, Moderator, Movies Host, Subscriber, UK Host

Joined: 8/17/2007
Posts: 42,771
Points: 524,688
Location: United Kingdom
SwiftMann wrote:
As for these two, while similar they aren't the same. Inspired? Perhaps, but not a direct homage.

There's no question Crisis came from X-Men. And unless there's something somewhere stating that X-Men is from Lois Lane, I don't believe it's an assumption we make as there's only so many ways to draw "holding a dead body."









I have to disagree. I know you're a huge X-Men fan, but it's a little absurd to suggest that the Crisis cover was inspired by X-Men #136. It's clearly the Lois Lane #128 issue, which after all was 1972 and also features Superman. Look at the arrangement of the background characters too. The tag for X-Men #136 is a bit of a fudge as there were plenty of other covers similar to it published before.

Incidentally, I've asked George Perez on facebook, which of the two covers he took inspiration from.


Marvel Universe® ~ No-one Ever Really Dies.

Make sure that you read and understand the forum rules here
SwiftMann
Posted: Saturday, March 08, 2014 7:46:43 AM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CCL Feature Crew, CR-Guidelines, Member, Super Seller

Shop at My Store

Joined: 4/19/2007
Posts: 11,327
Points: 1,928,598
Location: PA
So, making an argument that the two central figures on Crisis are identically posed as those on X-Men is "absurd," but "they both have Superman" is reasonable? Right...

Has DC Done Something Stupid Today?

"The return of beards and 90's fashion makes hipsters and homeless people impossible to tell apart." - Woody, Quantum & Woody #5
icarus201
Posted: Saturday, March 08, 2014 11:00:53 AM

Rank: Beyonder
Groups: Approver, CR-Policies, Member, Moderator, Movies Host, Subscriber, UK Host

Joined: 8/17/2007
Posts: 42,771
Points: 524,688
Location: United Kingdom
SwiftMann wrote:
So, making an argument that the two central figures on Crisis are identically posed as those on X-Men is "absurd," but "they both have Superman" is reasonable? Right...

Nope. You missed the point completely. I'm stating that it was more obvious that the Crisis cover was directly inspired from the Lois Lane cover because that precedes the X-Men cover by at least 8 years. Is it a co-incidence that both the DC covers feature Superman in an identical pose, but George was quoting John Byrne instead? Anyway, we'll see what Mr. Perez himself has to say when he gets back to me.


Marvel Universe® ~ No-one Ever Really Dies.

Make sure that you read and understand the forum rules here
Users browsing this topic
Guest


Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Main Forum RSS : RSS

This page was generated in 0.245 seconds.

ADVERTISEMENT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
All images on comic collector live copyright of their respective publishers. © Copyright 2008, MidTen Media Inc. GOLO231