Good but not great.
Review for New Mutants (2009) 4-A

Comic Book by Marvel, Oct 01 2009
     
 
Wishlist   
Ordered
No
In Cart
No

Good but not great.

In the absence (cancellation) of my favourite series, New X-Men, I suppose I should be thankful for a new series that slightly resembles it. And I was a huge fan of the original new Mutant series. I have to admit though, I don't think this team should still be acting like a bunch of kids. Sam Guthrie came across as the same goofy corn poke from the eighties. What does he have to be insecure about? Lets be perfectly honest, Dani Moonstone should hit the road, she's not a damn mutant anymore!

Take a brief walk back in time to the Children of the Vault story arc, and you find a leather clad, scruffy Cannonball with swagger to spare. Likewise for Sunspot. Going from leader of the hellfire Club to taking orders like an obedient dog from Cannonball...I'm not buying it!

That said, the Legion story has been pretty good. The teddy bear idea is creative and matches well with how I interpret Legion. I also never have a problem with Magik chopping people up with her Soul Sword.

So far the stories might be a little too self contained for my liking. This usually creates the feeling that the characters are not important enough to interact with the mainstream comic universe, and readers pick up on the vibe quickly.

I'm looking forward to seeing Warlock in the next issue, he can only make this team better.
     

Capekiller
September 02, 2009

Comments

Bristow1
Since I am a online subscriber I have three more issues on order, so if it doesn't get any better it will join Cable on the cancel line.
Bristow1
I agree with you on New X-men was pretty awesome. I was excited when I heard this series was coming out, being one of my favorite's from the 80's (yes I am that old). However this has been miserable..

For Sale

Sort
Alpha Comics
pottersan
Hero Mortal Villain
1245 11 2
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Astonishing Adventures
theseriouscollector
Hero Mortal Villain
1335 13 3
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%

All images on comic collector live copyright of their respective publishers. © Copyright 2025, Panel Logic Media Inc. PL-CCL