A bad new direction in ever...

A bad new direction in every way.
Review for Batgirl (2011) 35-A

Comic Book by DC, Dec 01 2014
     
 
  Details   Reviews   Stats    

Review By

     

Tamwood
October 08, 2014

A bad new direction in every way.

I was personally not a fan of bringing Barbara back as Batgirl. I thought that Cassandra Cain was a very good Batgirl, and that Stephanie Brown, as her replacement, was starting to come into her own with DC did their "it's not a reboot" reboot.

That said, I grew into new stories about Barbara as Batgirl. I think this new direction, however, is weak. They really didn't give a good reason for the change. I think the new writers tried too hard to give her "current" lingo (the term "bae" is used, for God's sake). The new costume, while it would look good on Stephanie doesn't look right on Barbara.

They've de-aged her to 21 (or lied about her age in this issue), but the new art makes her look like she's 12, and that's BEFORE the teeny-bopper outfit. And, in this issue, she used what I consider bad judgment, especially for a character that's been so deeply ingrained as being remarkably serious.

It's just a wrong direction, and a wrong creative team. I think the new artist can do some fabulous pin-up work. The incentive cover is very nicely drawn (although it's on the wrong Batgirl), but her interior art was too cluttered, and again, she looks way too young.

Comments

wcharrison355
Agreed!

My ComicCollectorLive
Not in Wishlist Wishlist
No
Not in a Current Order Ordered
No
Not in a Cart In Cart
No

For Sale

Sort
Titan Comics
jeremyshorr
Hero Mortal Villain
1588 5 3
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%
Bucky's Comics
Kingsman
Hero Mortal Villain
2313 4 1
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%

All images on comic collector live copyright of their respective publishers. © Copyright 2025, Panel Logic Media Inc. PL-CCL