Plenty of misses, but some great hits and a low, low price!
Review for Image Holiday Special 2005 nn-A

Graphic Novel / Trade by Image, Jan 01 2005
     
 
Wishlist   
Ordered
No
In Cart
No

Plenty of misses, but some great hits and a low, low price!

Image Holiday Special 2005 - This was an overall good collection of stories from across the Image line, in color, for only $10. Very nice package and generally very fun. The rundown is as follows.

Mr. Glum: "Holiday Special 1" and Glum & Dragon: "Holiday Special 2" - Two one pagers. Both pee jokes. Awesome.

PvP - My first PvP exposure. This was a cute story of the PvP characters going to the Image holiday party. Funny in that cute, wink-wink way.

Savage Dragon - I generally don't like Mr. Glum, but this was a good solo story done in a b&w snow scene with red as the only cover (yeah, it's a Frank Miller rip, but it's still good).

Scenes from a Bar on Christmas Eve 1-8 - This was a series of one-pagers spread through the book. Very interesting, true to life shorts ranging from scamming on chicks to bitching about the commercialism of Christmas.

Amazing Joy Buzzards and the Christmas Troll! - Wow. This was just bad. A Troll vs Santa and a wrestler. Didn't make a damn bit of sense and the art didn't do much for me.

G-Man and the Christmas Tree of Doom - Another cute one that had a forced ending, but hey, it's only an 8 page story. It had to come together. I'd love to see more Bullpen Bits over G-Man though.

The Battle Hymn: Mid-Nite Mass - This silent story went right over my head. Wonderful art though.

ShadowHawk: Just Another Christmas Story - Yup. Just another predictable Christmas story. Nothing special, but not offensive.

Opening Presents with Benito and Nate! - These two guys had a run in the back of some Kirkman book for a while. They tend to think they're a lot funnier than they really are. Nothing great here either, but again, not offensive.

Spawn - I'm not sure I fully got Brian Haberlin's story here, but from what I got I liked. Nice art too.

Godland: Early Christmas Story - Santa and a skull-headed visitor smoke a bowl. Nice!

Noble Causes: Snow Job - The most enjoyable Noble Causes I've ever read. Not high praise, but at least it was fun and I loved the art, particularly on the snow man's facial expressions.

Gray Area Story - The f**k?!

Buddy Henson's Unexplained Mysteries Story - Cute do-you-believe-in-Santa story from Chris Eliopolious. This pretty much was another Franklin Richards story with generic characters. Fine by me!

The Walking Dead Story - Holy crap. Kirkman went back to the father & son who moved into Rick's house way back in issue one or two. A great little story.
     

SwiftMann
June 22, 2009

Comments

No Comments

For Sale

Sort

All images on comic collector live copyright of their respective publishers. © Copyright 2025, Panel Logic Media Inc. PL-CCL