Proper Ending
Review for X-Men: Magneto Testament 5-A

Comic Book by Marvel, Mar 01 2009
     
 
Wishlist   
Ordered
No
In Cart
No

Proper Ending

This is going to bring down the wrath on your's truly, but I will forget this series pretty quickly. It was very well written and the art really helped with the story telling. But I found it to be very cliché. It was the same story that has been told one thousand times over. I know it is not good form to get down on "art" with this type of subject matter. But keep in mind this is a comic review, not a commentary on the Holocaust. I am, and have been, every bit horrified by these acts my whole life. I just thought they maybe could have taken a little bit more original view on the events. Instead, I was shown what every movie showsm. What every book tells me and what every lecture I've ever heard has ingrained in me. I actually found the story/info at the end about Dina Gottliebova to be far more interesting than anything the main story provided. That would have made a better five issue mini series. With all this being said though, the book as a stand alone issue within a five issue run, was very good. It just didn't pique my curiosity very much.
     

Capekiller
February 07, 2009

Comments

No Comments

For Sale

Sort
Edgewood Comics
DGarman
Hero Mortal Villain
1087 3 0
  • Satisfaction Rate: 100%

All images on comic collector live copyright of their respective publishers. © Copyright 2025, Panel Logic Media Inc. PL-CCL