"Nightmare!"
8 pages.
"Television Terror!"
7 pages.
"Repeat Performance"
1 page, text only.
"Monster Maker!"
6 pages.
"The Witch's Cauldron: Horror Beneath the Streets!"
Bill Gaines and Al Feldstein are chased below the streets of New York and coerced by the Vault-Keeper and the Crypt-Keeper to produce their stories, which debut in the next issue. 7 pages.
First appearances of the Crypt-Keeper and the Vault-Keeper.
Reprinted in Haunt of Fear (RCP) #3 in its entirety with the exception of the text story.
Note: this issue continues the numbering from the western-themed title, Gunfighter, and indicates issue #17 on the cover. EC would adjust the numbering as of the next issue (to issue #4) per the request of the USPS.